Artists That Plagiarized From Other Artists… Or Did They?

(Hypebot) — Did Dua Lipa steal the musical parts from a track she heard in an elevator? Preserve studying to seek out out.

A visitor publish by Bobby Owsinski of Music 3.0.

You may say that it began to get uncontrolled with “Blurred Traces” choice again in 2015. That’s when the property of Marvin Gaye won the case and enchantment that Robin Thicke’s “Blurred Traces” appropriated the texture of Gaye’s “Gotta Give It Up.” Yep, you’re not supposed to have the ability to copyright a really feel of a track, however there you will have it. Since then there’s been a line of copyright infringement lawsuits (Tom Petty vs Sam Smith, Ed Sheeran vs Marvin Gaye for starters), some seemingly respectable and others not a lot, in addition to landmark circumstances like George Harrison vs The Chiffons, John Fogerty vs John Fogerty, the Rolling Stones vs The Verve and tons extra.

We’ve run into a giant downside within the songwriting and publishing enterprise – there are solely so many notes and chords that may be organized in a satisfying means. Most of them have already been accomplished, so nothing is really new.

Let’s Levitate

That newest high-profile case is being introduced by Artikal Sound System towards Dua Lipa saying that she copied their “Reside Your Life” monitor for her big multinational hit “Levitating.” Like most courtroom circumstances there are many nuances. Artikal Sound System has subsequent to no distribution and never a lot publicity (the track wasn’t even on the varied streaming websites or the CD obtainable on the market till the lawsuit) and it solely had a single radio station taking part in it. Sarcastically, that station was used as elevator music in a resort that Dua Lipa stayed in on tour, however there’s no proof that she truly heard the track throughout her keep.

However as you’ll see within the wonderful evaluation by Adam Neely under, there are many songs that predate each “Levitating” and “Reside Your Life” going again to Outcast’s “Rosa Parks” in 1998.

However wait! There’s extra.

It Goes Again Additional

The rhythm used for all these songs and a bunch of others truly was initially created and copy-written means again in 1923. It’s known as “The Charleston.” However that was truly appropriated by white musicians from a standard rhythm utilized by black musicians even earlier than 1923. Both means, it’s now within the public area, so there ought to be no foundation for this specific lawsuit.

The purpose right here is that there are solely 12 notes in scale for Western music, and there are solely so some ways they are often organized in a means that’s pleasing to our ears. Similar with chord adjustments and rhythms. The purpose is, there’s been a whole bunch of years of music written beforehand, so something written at this time is borrowing not less than one thing from music of the previous.

Copyright Modifications

Perceive that I’m not an lawyer so that you’re getting an informed layman’s opinion right here, nevertheless it’s been apparent for years that copyright wants some critical reform. Since all of the mixtures have been written earlier than, does that imply there ought to be no infringement? No, however wouldn’t it work higher if infringement was based mostly extra on how a lot of a earlier work was used, say like 8 bars?

If the texture of the track is really topic to copyright, shouldn’t the size have a bearing on infringement as properly? Or possibly a mixture of all the above.

Nonetheless you take a look at it, there’s a variety of confusion being sown within the artist and songwriter group about what constitutes infringement, and even these supposedly within the know are simply as confused. It’s time for some readability.

Did Dua Lipa ACTUALLY Plagiarize Levitating? [VIDEO]

Bobby Owsinski is a producer/engineer, writer and coach. He has authored 24 books on recording, music, the music enterprise and social media.

Learn extra: https://music3point0.com/2022/03/09/the-music-industry-is-eating-itself-alive-with-copyright-infringement-lawsuits/#ixzz7NDGtN0dC
Beneath Inventive Commons License: Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike