If he remembers a missed prayer during the current prayer or after finishing it

ByCelebrities Buzz

Question My question is about the missed prayer. If I for example pray the Maghrib of today then remembered that my Fajr prayer of the last week was invalid, like if I passed wind during the prayer. If at that time I just doubted it but afterwards I felt it was sure that I passed…

Question

My question is about the missed prayer. If I for example pray the Maghrib of today then remembered that my Fajr prayer of the last week was invalid, like if I passed wind during the prayer. If at that time I just doubted it but afterwards I felt it was sure that I passed wind, or that my wudu was incomplete, like if I remember that there was something was on my foot while I was making wudu for this salaah and I did not remove it! Is it permissible to repeat the missed prayer after I finish praying the Maghrib of today then I repeat the Maghrib again as Fajr normally comes before Maghrib? Or it is appropriate to just repeat the missed prayer without repeating the current one, as the missed Fajr was of another day?.

Praise be to Allah.

If you have prayed
the current prayer, then you remember a missed prayer from the same day or a
previous day, you should pray it, but do not repeat the current prayer,
because the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said:
“Whoever forgets a prayer, let him offer it as soon as he remembers, for
there is no expiation for it other than that. ‘and perform As‑Salaah
(Iqaamat‑as‑Salaah) for My remembrance’ [Ta-Ha 20:14].” Narrated by
al-Bukhaari (597) and Muslim (684).

Al-Nawawi (may
Allaah have mercy on him) said: The words of the Prophet (peace and
blessings of Allaah be upon him), “Whoever forgets a prayer, let him offer
it as soon as he remembers, for there is no expiation for it other than
that” mean: nothing will make up for it except a prayer like it, and he does
not have to do anything else. End quote.

Based on this, then
in the case asked about here, you have to pray Fajr as soon as you remember
it, and do not repeat Maghrib.

But if a person
remembers a missed prayer during the current prayer, should he complete it
or interrupt it? There is a difference of opinion among the fuqaha’. Abu
Haneefah and Maalik were of the view that the current prayer becomes
invalid, so he should offer the missed prayer first and then the current
prayer. The Shaafa’is were of the view that he should complete the current
prayer and then offer the missed the prayer, and it is mustahabb for him to
repeat the current prayer. Ahmad was of the view that he should complete the
current prayer, then make up the missed prayer, then repeat the current
prayer as something obligatory.

This has been
discussed in the answer to question no.
30788, where we stated that
repeating the current prayer is better, in order to be on the safe side.

And Allaah knows
best.

Similar Posts

Les propos des ulémas sur les dates de naissance et de décès du Prophète (Bénédiction et salut soient sur lui) et le mieux argumenté d’entre eux

ByCelebrities Buzz

Question Quelles sont les dates de naissance et de décès du Messager d’Allah (Bénédiction et salut soient sur lui)? Je dispose de beaucoup d’opinions sur la question. Quel est l’avis juste et son argument tiré du livre et de la Sunna? Quelles sont les dates de naissance et de décès du Messager d’Allah (Bénédiction et…

Si Jesús era Dios, ¿cómo podía Él orar a Dios? ¿Estaba Cristo orando a Sí mismo?

ByCelebrities Buzz

Pregunta Si Jesús era Dios, ¿cómo podía Él orar a Dios? ¿Estaba Cristo orando a Sí mismo? [] [] Respuesta Para comprender a Jesús como Dios en la tierra, orando a Su Padre en el Cielo, tenemos que considerar que el Padre eterno y el Hijo eterno tenían una relación eterna antes que Jesús tomara…

What are the six classes of essential nutrients?

ByCelebrities Buzz

Nutrients can be grouped into six categories: carbohydrate, protein, lipid (fat), water, vitamins, and minerals (see table 8.1). These six nutrients are further classified according to size and energy. Carbohydrate, protein, and fat are macronutrients because they make up the bulk of your diet.Click to see full answer. Keeping this in consideration, what are the…

ख्रिस्ती व्यक्ती श्रापित होऊ शकतो का? देव विश्वास ठेवणाऱ्या व्यक्तीवर श्राप देऊ देईल का?

ByCelebrities Buzz

प्रश्नः ख्रिस्ती व्यक्ती श्रापित होऊ शकतो का? देव विश्वास ठेवणाऱ्या व्यक्तीवर श्राप देऊ देईल का? उत्तरः पवित्र शास्त्र आपल्याला सांगते की “भ्रमण करणारी चिमणी व उडणारी निळवी ह्यांच्याप्रमाणे निष्कारण दिलेला शाप कोठेच ठरत नाही” (नीतिसूत्रे 26:2 ब). याचा अर्थ असा की मूर्ख शापांचा काहीही परिणाम होत नाही. देव आपल्या मुलांना शाप देऊ देत नाही. देव…

Da li je moguće prodati svoju dušu đavolu?

ByCelebrities Buzz

Pitanje Da li je moguće prodati svoju dušu đavolu? Odgovor U izmišljenoj priči o Doktoru Faustu, čovjek napravi pogodbu sa đavolom: u zamjenu za svoje tijelo i dušu, primiće nadnaravnu silu i zadovoljstva 24 godine. Đavo pristane na tu razmjenu i Dr. Faust uživa te užitke grijeha jedno vrijeme, ali mu je sudbina zapečaćena. Nakon…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.