Is there any copyright on the Mushaf for the printer or programmer?
Question I downloaded the Qur’an from some websites, then I uploaded it onto my website so that people can download it and read it. The problem now is that the site from which I downloaded the Qur’an is asking me to remove the Holy Qur’an from my website, but I am hesitant to do it,…
Question
The problem now is that the site from which I downloaded the Qur’an is asking me to remove the Holy Qur’an from my website, but I am hesitant to do it, because it is Qur’an and there is no copyright on it
I would like to ask you: how should I deal with this matter, because it is causing me a great deal of anxiety, as I want to keep the Qur’an on my website, but they are asking me to remove it.
I would also like to add that they have not translated this Qur’an themselves, rather they usually upload it or take it from another website.
In fact I need your advice about this matter; I am also asking Allah to guide me to what is right, because I want to earn the reward of this deed and not lose it.
Praise be to Allah.
It is the
right of authors of books and programs, for which they have gone to the
effort of producing and publishing them, that the copyright should be
protected, and they may prevent others from publishing, printing or
producing this material except with their permission, as we have explained
in the answers to questions no. 95173,
454, 21899 and
26307.
The Mushaf
is the book of Allah, may He be exalted, and no one has the right to claim
copyright on publishing, printing and distributing it, as far as the content
is concerned, unless he has put effort into that which means that he is
entitled to copyright, such as one who prints it with a commentary (tafseer)
in the margins or the meanings of the words, or one who publishes it in a
program for which he has expended money and effort. In such cases, their
rights are protected, as we have explained in the answer to question no.
126897
Hence if
the Mushaf that you have downloaded from that website is something for which
the site owners have clearly put effort into programming it and preparing it
in a form that they have invented, then they have the right to prevent you
from publishing it unless that is done with their consent, and they have the
right to protection of their copyright, not for the Book itself, but for the
effort they put into programming.
But if the
Mushaf is available on other websites and it is clear to you that they are
not in fact the owners, and that the effort put into producing it did not
come from them, and that its producers have given it to people for free,
then you do not have to do respond to their request to remove it from your
website.
If it so
happens that you have erased the copy that you downloaded from their
website, then you can upload another copy from those that are available on
the Internet, which will mean that you have no need for that copy.
And Allah
knows best.
